Bread & Roses Theatre, London – until 3 August 2019
For this week only, the capital can again savour the vocal excellence of Molly Lynch in her one-woman show Rodgers and Hammerstein & Me Too. The titular pun is deliberate as the accomplished Lynch takes her audience through a dozen or so R&H classics, interspersed with verbatim references to a selected choice of recent years’ headline stories.
Lynch is a magnificent performer with the tightly packed hour long show demonstrating not only her ability to sing – but also a perfectly nuanced knack to act through song too. And for some of the evening the emotional punch of the stories she relates are painful and poignant.
The interweaving of Kyle Stephens’ testimonies – a woman who as a young child was horrendously abused by America’s notorious paedophile Larry Nassar – with the lyrics of ‘My Favourite Things’ from The Sound Of Music proves powerful and heartbreaking. But there are moments when the counterpoint is clumsy. Contexting Rose McGowan’s description of Harvey Weinstein’s vile behaviour to a backdrop of the comparatively sugary sweetness of ‘That’s The Way It Happens’ from Me And Juliet is an intended irony that misses the mark
Save for a brief reference to Jimmy Savile, Lynch’s politicking is aimed squarely (and disappointingly, politically correctly) at the USA. This being the “woke” 2019, her failure to reference either the numerous misogynist regimes around the world that see women treated appallingly or, closer to home, the thousands of young girls in the UK that are and have been preyed upon by grooming gangs, are glaring omissions.
Most fine musical theatre songs are best left unadulterated and, above all, uninterrupted. Good songwriting should tell its story and pack its punch through melody and lyric and it takes a fine and subtle hand to meddle with a masterpiece effectively. If Lynch returns to the intimacy of a cabaret venue – and one sincerely hope she does – the politics could perhaps be parked in favour of an evening that breaks the fourth wall and shines some light on the genius that underlies this young woman who is surely one of Ireland’s most talented exports.
When Katherine Jenkins played Julie Jordan in the Coliseum’s Carousel a couple of years ago, Lynch was her acclaimed understudy and it remains a source of regret to many (Jonathan Baz included) that they missed those rare occasions that saw her step up to the leading role. This concert however offered some solace, with Lynch including What’s The Use Of Wond’rin’ in her set list. Her take on the song is exquisite, showcasing one of the finest voices to be found in London.
Runs until 3rd August